Our Carriers

As an independent agency, we represent dozens of insurers, including

Carnahan Insurance offers smart insurance solutions for Texas businesses, homes and families! A lot of things don’t matter…until they do! Insurance is one of those.

Jerry R. Carnahan started the Carnahan Insurance Agency in 1977, and since then we have been providing individuals and businesses throughout Texas with quality coverage at the best available price. We specialize in Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Business Insurance and Individual Life Insurance as well as other Personal Insurance and Employee Benefits products.

Our Testimonials

“Carnahan Insurance has saved my family a lot of money over the years by shopping insurance companies for me. Thank you Carnahan Insurance!”

Van C.PERSONAL & COMMERCIAL LINES CUSTOMER, SAN ANTONIO, TX

“By switching my policy to Carnahan Insurance, I was able to receive big savings on my auto policy. I can’t thank them enough for getting me the right coverage at the right price.”

Adriana G.AUTO INSURANCE CUSTOMER, TEXAS

“The folks at Carnahan Insurance are number #1 for homeowners insurance in Texas. I have peace of mind knowing that I don’t have just any coverage for my home, I have the RIGHT coverage.”

Mark S.HOMEOWNERS INSURANCE CUSTOMER, SAN ANTONIO, TX

“Carnahan Insurance is a business partner I can trust. Local and knowledgeable, they’ve satisfied (and exceeded) my expectations. The staff is truthful in explaining my coverage and I receive the service that I trust and value.”

Mike J.COMMERCIAL INSURANCE CUSTOMER, SAN ANTONIO, TX

“Carnahan Insurance has always been there for me and my family throughout the years. They go above and beyond, and I am very pleased with the entire staff. Thank you, Carnahan Insurance!”

Carl W.AUTO INSURANCE CUSTOMER, SAN ANTONIO, TX
Meet Our Team

Jerry Carnahan

President

Gracie Castaneda

Account Manager

Delia Garza

Account Manager

Monica Trevino

Account Manager

Adam Thompson

Account Manager

Andrew DeJesus

Digital Strategist

Carnahan's Workers' Comp Awards

Jerry Carnahan quite literally wrote the book on Workers’ Comp! He is the co-author of the Texas edition of Stop Being Frustrated & Overcharged, a book about reducing Workers’ Compensation costs.

Since 2016, Carnahan Insurance has presented the Controllable Premium Award to companies in recognition of their outstanding workers’ comp premium savings.

Learn more about our recent recipients below.

Carnahan Insurance - H.J otis plumbing co

San Antonio Workers’ Comp Award Given to H.J. Otis Plumbing Company

Read More
think safety award

Tower Tech Services Wins San Antonio Workers’ Comp Award

Read More
Elgin's A_c & heating

Elgin’s A/C & Heating Wins San Antonio Workers’ Comp Award

Read More
At Carnahan Insurance Agency, our mission is very simple. We strive to provide a true, concierge client experience which is unique in the insurance industry. We give clients the power of choice from top-rated national and regional insurance carriers. We offer comprehensive insurance solutions in San Antonio and throughout the state of Texas.